Rogue Police Or Plutocrat Controlled?

“Men use thought only as authority for their injustice, and employ speech only to conceal their thoughts.”  –  Voltaire


Two reports have surfaced recently, pretty close together, that has me concerned about the state of the police force in NY City.   The first comes from a neighborhood news blog called New York about a young couple – Matthew Swaye, 35, and his partner Christina Gonzalez, 25 – who see themselves as “peace activists” and are engaged in going about the city video taping police officers as they enact “search and frisk” measures  on people who they feel look suspicious.  In doing this Swaye and Gonzalez have incurred the ire of the NYPD by posting what clearly looked like a criminal “wanted poster” of Matthew and Christina, seen in this YouTube video taken by the young couple.

“Be aware that above subjects are known professional agitators,” read the flyer, which bears the NYPD shield and a seal of the NYPD‘s Intelligence Division. It also gave the home address of the couple.

“Above subjects MO is that they video tape officers performing routine stops and post on YouTube,” the sign said. “Subjects purpose is to portray officers in a negative way and to deter officers from conducting there [sic] responsibilities.”   SOURCE

Though the claim that Swaye and Gonzalez are attempting to prevent law enforcement officials from doing their job appears serious, NYPD has taken no action to charge them with a crime or arrest them, which leaves reasonable people to believe that the two have done nothing illegal.  After this video went public the wanted poster came down.

Apparently both Mr. Swaye and Ms. Gonzalez were previously arrested in a protest of NY city’s beefed-up “search and frisk” practicealong with several others including author and political activist Dr. Cornell West.   Ms. Gonzales allegedly took a swipe at one of the officers at this protest and was charged with 2nd degree assault.  In a separate incident Ms. Gonzalez was also held on a contempt charge in Rikers Island jail after refusing to apologize for calling “controversial and conservative Brooklyn Judge John H. Wilson a ‘white racist pig.’”

A couple of videos recorded by the couple show they are in-your-face style activists which can come across as annoying.  Here’s one of Matthew dogging NYC police commissioner Raymond Kelly leaving a building and another of Christina chastising officers for taking a woman out of a court building, face down in a bag after she allegedly was “beaten for asking to use the rest restroom” according to Ms. Gonzalez.  The video is at night so there is no light to surmise if what Ms. Gonzalez is telling us is in fact what’s occurring.  Though I found both of these video’s a little unsettling in how these peace activists go about their task, I saw no violence and property damage on their part.

It’s understandable why some of the city’s men and women in blue would view Gonzalez and Swaye as “agitators”.  In their zeal the young couple are abrasive, no matter how justifiable their concerns may be.  Add to this the daily friction police officers endure dealing with the public.  Police officers, who have a suicide rate that is twice that of the general population, have one of the most stressful occupations on the planet according to Hans Selye, one of the foremost researchers in stress-related activities.   But their training should teach them how to deal with “agitators” and prevent them from stepping over the line, doing things that are clearly unprofessional and which only enhance further animosity.

What makes this action taken against Swaye and Gonzalez by the NYPD look even more egregious is the second story I came across shortly afterwards.

Investigators have connected DNA evidence from the scene of Sarah Fox’s murder in Inwood Hill Park eight years ago to DNA collected at the scene of an Occupy Wall Street subway station vandalism in March.

Fox, 21, was found nude and strangled in the park in May 2004, days after she disappeared during a daytime jog. Investigators recovered her pink CD player in the woods just yards from her body.

Sources said Tuesday the DNA found on the CD player is linked to DNA found on a chain left by Occupy Wall Street protesters at the Beverly Road subway station in East Flatbush on March 28, 2012. 

That Wednesday morning, protesters chained open emergency gates and taped up turnstiles in eight subway stations and posted fliers encouraging riders to enter for free.   SOURCE

The story headline and part of the story display a bit of professional bias, conspicuously connecting the Occupy Wall Street (OWS) movement with the protest where the chain with the incriminating DNA was found.  The reporters who broke this story for New York’s NBC affiliate said the chain found with the DNA on it was one  “used in a recent Occupy Wall Street protest.”  Yet deeper into their story they cite the communique from the The Rank and File Initiative that informed viewers of how “teams of activists, many from Occupy Wall Street, in conjunction with rank and file workers from the Transport Workers Union Local 100 and the Amalgamated Transit Union, opened up more than 20 stations across the city for free entry.”

The fact that other groups were involved, perhaps to the same degree, should have prevented an honest journalist from using only the more popular OWS group in their headline as the one’s associated with where the chain was found.   It’s still unclear why the NYC police department would be checking for DNA at such an event, unless they had some investigative data that linked one of the protesters of any of the groups with Ms. Fox’s murder in 2004.  Congratulations might have been in order for the great forensic work the police have done here but a follow-up story by NBC New York suggests that it was perhaps after all a simple case of contamination by a city laboratory technician.


But knowing that there has been animosity between the police and the Manhattan OWS movement for months and in view of the culpability of some within the NYPD to try and discredit them – as they clearly did with Matthew Swaye and Christina Gonzalez – raises the uncomfortable feeling that the DNA that was surprisingly discovered, to a crime eight years earlier, may have been a set-up to further discredit a movement that many of the city’s well-healed citizens have disparaged openly since their first sit-in back in September, 2011.   The Occupy movement is once again brought into a bad public light to further vilify them after a possible mistake that some poor slug at the lower echelons has to take the blame for.  This whole thing has dubious considerations to ponder.

I would love to ask “Emmy-award winning reporter” Jonathan Dienst who shared this story with his NBC 4 producer, Shimon Prokupecz what motivated them to put  OccupyWallStreet in their headline.  NBC, which is a part of NBCUniversal Media, LLC, is owned by both media conglomerate Comcast and the multi-national corporation of General Electric.  Corporate-owned media in this country owns the vast resources of which gives us our news on the air waves, on-line and now on social media.  It’s always been feared by some that with this relatively new arrangement, many of the stories that reflect poorly on the wealthy and the businesses they own often get white-washed or omitted completely as a result of back room deals between the corporate ownership and the news departments they own.   The Occupy movement has been a thorn in the side of wealthy corporate interests from day one.

I don’t want to be any part of allegations that unjustifiably tries to portray as villains those who fight crime in this country and provide a thin blue line of defense between the criminal and their potential victims. Though clearly there are always those who fail to live up to their role as a law enforcement officer, it is often the result of someone who has given a lifetime of service that seldom gets the recognition they feel they deserve, leading them to take matters into their own hands.  Coupled with this are the abuses by some within law enforcement who have developed some higher notion of authority that allows them to act outrageously through some sense of “the greater good.”   I honestly don’t think anyone deliberately goes into to law enforcement to bully those who annoy the plutocrats in this country.

It’s important that when such abuses occur within the police department that a vigilant citizenry and their governmental representatives act swiftly and with clear thinking to ensure that the elements within who hurt the larger department are weeded out before it taints all others who courageously put their lives on the line for all of us everyday.  But there is every reason to believe that powerful people utilize the police to protect their special interests and are not beyond using tactics that push the civil rights envelope.  Idealistic men and women who join police departments in large urban areas to fight crime are often unaware they are the pawns of people who pull the strings in government.  People who depend upon this relationship do so to shield themselves from prosecution by an outraged public.

Discord between poor minorities and those who “serve and protect” the public has always been an area of concern for both policy makers and citizen groups who work to achieve harmony in communities where poverty and crime breed.  When either side takes action that enhances this disharmony it only makes it that much more difficult to accomplish productive goals.

Public awareness is key here and ideological differences should not overtake the importance of what is at stake.  Stories like these need to be viewed rationally and methodically and absent any “them versus us” contingent we all seem to harbor.  But they also need to be weighed in terms of what kind of message are the power brokers at the top sending the little people below them?  It has become crystal clear that white-collar crime doesn’t seem to attract the ire of our judicial system in this country as much as it used to and when something does occur by a member of the wealthy 1%, they usually pay what appears to most people as a healthy fine but hardly breaks a sweat from the violator, all while they remain free rather than serving time.

Evidence of this was laid out by Matt Taibi, a real journalist who duly noted that following the financial crisis that brought our economy to its knees, “one that saw virtually every major bank and financial company on Wall Street embroiled in obscene criminal scandals that impoverished millions and collectively destroyed hundreds of billions, in fact, trillions of dollars of the world’s wealth — … nobody went to jail. Nobody, that is, except Bernie Madoff, a flamboyant and pathological celebrity con artist, whose victims happened to be other rich and famous people.”


I have as much authority as the Pope, I just don’t have as many people who believe it.  – George Carlin



L.A. Riot Police clash with near Art Walk

Austerity Gestapo Brutally Attacks Peaceful Protestors in Spain


10 responses to “Rogue Police Or Plutocrat Controlled?

  1. Great piece…this has been happening all over the country. On Thursday in LA there was a local event called Art Walk taking place and Occupy had promoted it on their Facebook page as Chalk Walk and was going to hand out chalk for people to make their own art on the sidewalks. This prompted LA riot police to show up and they ended up arresting 17 people. It is insane how militarized our local police are becoming.

    • Thanks Angela. I’m glad you reminded of the protest at the Oakland Art Walk too. I added that article to my “Related Articles” list at the bottom of this post.

  2. Great piece. I think the police have been given too much power at times. Anyone who does not think that the police taint facts to sway public perception are naive. This is why I am a fierce believer in no publicity about trials before trials. So many innocent people have been locked up because of information the police leak out to “make” their cases. It was no accident they linked Occupy Wall Street with this murder in some way. When the police do this type of biased information dissemination, they make their case in the media instead of a court of law and the media won’t balk because they get sensational headlines. It’s a win-win situation for two entities whose one hand washes the other relationship has reached a scary status as well.

    • Thanks Donna. My biggest concern is the police around the country and around the world will allow their baser, survival instincts to kick in and go with the side that they feel best butters their bread – the rich, since government budget cuts now minimize the impact on their salaries being part of what OUR taxes pay for. Let’s hope I am wrong.

  3. Excellent piece Larry…….I worry for protest in this country…the PDs are getting military grade weaponry….and if things go the way they are trending then protests will be hazardous to your health…

  4. For nearly 20 years I spent an inordinate amount of time with cops. I worked with them/against them, every day, and dated quite a number over the years. The problem is that police work invites those who are powerless and who feel abused by govt. So they get to be govt, and carry a gun. It’s the wrong mix–they are authoritarian types suddenly given the ability to push people around. That comprises way too many of our police forces today. The ones who are good are in many ways victims of all the lousy ones. I always said, I don’t care if police lie or not, as long as they get the RIGHT person and finesse things enough so that the criminal doesn’t see the cop as every bit as crooked as they are. When you lie and don’t care if you get the right guy, you are a miserable sob. I haven’t been around cops much in the last 20 years. I don’t know if they are more militaristic or not. They are certainly up against it a lot, and for that I feel badly, but I also feel that much is missed in terms of community service. It’s a tough issue.

  5. I’m not so sure we can put this all on “Rouge” cops. it seems obvious to me and many others that bullying and brutality are quickly becoming the norm rather than the exception.
    Right here in Maryland; in the town I recently moved from; the police are almost all taking a very hard line with people and peoples rights are regularly trampled on.
    If you watch these guys in action it reminds you of the behavior of some more famous Fascists.
    Much like the Jews who stayed alive by beating their fellow prisoners for food and priviledges; the Police in this nation are in the business of beating and bullying whoever their wealthy masters tell them to. That means you and I.

    Protect and Serve?
    “Protect” the 1% and their cronies and “Serve” the rest of us up on a platter for their entertainment.

    We are occupying the wrong places. This Government will never give attention to us until we stop occupying parks and begin occupying courts, police stations and government buildings. Sit-ins etc. Civil Disobedience day after day until they get tired of hauling the bodies away. Occupy, occupy, occupy evrything that allows normal operations.

    No government in history has ever listened to protesters. They only listen when you tie them down or bog them down and make them listen. Let them keep the protests in areas that they chose and we will never be heard.

    Half of America barely knew what what the movement was about last summer.

    Half of America believes the movement died over the winter as predicted by the puppet media.

    I’ll be damned if I will stand in a park and beg for the attention of these Fascists and beg for their consideration.

    The time is now to DEMAND our rights; demand to be heard; demand an end to corporate influence and demand a new form of Government or ammendments to the old one that will assure the welfare of the 99% and do for them what the old system did for the 1%.

    You aren’t Occupying anything if you just go home when the nice policemen ask.

  6. “The time is now to DEMAND our rights; demand to be heard; demand an end to corporate influence and demand a new form of Government or ammendments to the old one that will assure the welfare of the 99% and do for them what the old system did for the 1%.”

    I surely understand your rage angryman and I think there are times when such more in-your-face- encounters have a strategic advantage. But effective protestations will take longer and need to be directed at the messaging entities of corporate America, the Media, and at the source of their own avarice – profits.

    There are still good journalists out there and we need to encourage a strong revival of traditional investigative reporting that seeks to expose corruption and malfeasance, no matter what Party they belong to. Simultaneously we need to use the power of our pocketbooks to boycott those media sources that whitewash the truth as well as those products made by corporations who fund those candidates that vote against the public’s best interests.

    Thanks for dropping by and sharing your comments

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s