Kill Medicaid and Medicare and You Eliminate Social Security

If wealthy financial interests cannot get the revenue that funds Social Security, then no one will.

I’m not the kind that sees conspiracies behind every corner and I’m not much of a patron of those popular conspiracies that appear to have some credibility, like some of those surrounding JFK’s  assassination.  But if I were to apply myself I could perhaps make a case that Paul Ryan and the GOP are out to eliminate Social Security through a slow process that entails shrinking Medicare and Medicaid to a form that allows more people to die before they reach retirement age.

Mr. Ryan has released the GOP budget plan for 2012 and in it is a proposal that would eliminate $1 trillion from the federal program that enables the poorest and most vulnerable amongst us to purchase health insurance and vital, life-saving prescription drugs for millions.   It doesn’t remove the $1 trillion from Medicaid immediately; doing it instead very slowly over a 10 year period.  A sort of “death by a thousand cuts” process.  It’s conceivable that the GOP hopes that benefits that are not realized by a generation whose age and health make them ineligible to tap into these benefits for years to come will go unnoticed long before they do see the value of such a program for themselves.

As the means to provide health services is reduced through the GOP’s voucher program, illnesses will become more prevalent and cures will be fewer for those who rely on this low cost health insurance, thus increasing the likelihood of death at an earlier age than would have otherwise occurred for senior citizens, poorer children and the disabled.  Already the GOP is working the other side of the tracks as they attempt to raise the age on Social Security eligibility to 70.

A 2007 GAO report shows that lower income people who are unable to provide adequate health care insurance die younger than their wealthier counterparts who can.

With this combination of higher eligibility rates for collecting SS benefits and poorer people dying off long before they reach that age due to inadequate health care coverage, the U.S. Treasury will have more money available; money that corporations will lobby for to subsidize their ventures while they re-invest their profits in share holder dividends and upper management bonuses.  And any real tax savings here will not significantly impact most middle income wage earners in this country.

A look at the GOP’s budget deficit reduction plan shows their “preferred treatment for Medicaid, outlined in a policy booklet called “A Roadmap for America’s Future,” … convert[s] current federal payments to states into direct assistance in the form of $11,000 per year per recipient, which could be used to purchase private insurance.” (GOP plans $1 trillion Medicaid cut, by Jonathon Allen, Politico, 3/31/11)

There is little in this “Roadmap” about cost of living adjustments (COLA) to deal with inflation and there most certainly are no restraints on the private sector to charge what they will for health care.  What $11,000 buys today in terms of treatment and necessary therapies will likely not cover such cost ten years from now and even less on down the road from that.  If this practice carries over to Medicare then the elderly along with children and the disabled will have fewer people to collect their Social Security benefits they have earned over time.

But surely the Republican Tea Party is not that cold and calculating.  Not everyone on the Right can be as conniving as Grover Norquist whose Americans for Tax Reform group, since 1989, has aligned itself with conservatives and business interests to shrink the government through tax and spending cuts to a size that “can be drowned in a bath tub”; tax cuts that benefit the wealthiest 2% more than anyone else.  However, that may not be as far-fetched as it seems.

Too many Americans have been convinced by GOP rhetoric that the budget is a spending issue, not a tax issue.  But anyone can clearly see a correlation between tax cuts, especially for the wealthiest amongst us and a short-changing of vital social services.  The specified taxes that come out of paychecks while paying for Medicare/Medicaid and Social Security are small in comparison if the majority of Americans were left to fend for themselves.

“Medicare, by means of cost controls and the distribution of risk, is the best deal going in health care by a third. To scrap Medicare would mean loss of that price leverage and higher prices for seniors that will likely end up being passed on to the sandwich generation” says Huffington Post commentator, Stephen Herrington.

“Vouchers for private insurance in lieu of Medicare … would instantly increase the federal deficit component for assistance to seniors by 30%, the cost advantage of Medicare over private plans. Anything less than full value would simply disproportionally shift the burden from government to a public already groaning under the weight of servicing medical profits. There are no net savings to the public here. (emphasis mine)  Servicing private profit is no less onerous than taxes.”

So is this a conceivable conspiracy by the GOP to kill benefits for low and middle-income families?  We don’t see any efforts to reduce the deficit with cuts in a bloated Defense budget.  Even Scrooge reluctantly agreed to support the Treadmill and the Poor Laws” that created a meager safety net for the poorest of the poor rather than allow for-profit efforts to take charge of this.  And so what if more people die sooner than they would without this aid that they have all contributed to throughout their working lives?  Decreasing this “surplus population” will only leave more in the Treasury for the wealthy patrons of Republicans to feed off of for years to come.


GAO Report: ‘Poverty in America: Consequences for Individuals and the Economy’ January 24, 2007.

GOP Budget Proposal for 2012 to Gut Medicaid


6 responses to “Kill Medicaid and Medicare and You Eliminate Social Security

  1. Americans are either silly or just plain dumb…the GOP has made it NO secret that they want to destroy SS and Medicare….since the day it was formed…..and yet we still vote for the people that would put us all in poverty…..we are not that bright when it comes to voting….

  2. They should stop giving these so called law makers free health care, and strip away their retirement benefits. Both paid for by the people on the lower end of the spectrum.

  3. I think the GOP thinks that if they can get rid of the poor and needy, their lives would be so much better. I don’t understand how anyone can support this party.

  4. To understand the attack on medicare you have to see the movie “Blow” with Johnny Depp. There is a scene where Depp’s character visits a Panama Bank after having trouble with the US Government. He is told that after an financial crisis in Panama his assets have been frozen to help the economy. The one percent that controls the US is worried that may happen here. Also from another perspective, Social Security is the last large piece of money that Wall Street cannot get their hands on. Thus the attack on Social Security. Look at how it affected home loans, student loans and 401K’s. They are worried that since health care is a “cash cow”, governmental underwritten health care will decrease there chance to make money.
    As Spike Lee stated on TV One last year. “Greed will be the death of America”.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s